Windmark Beach Homes for Sale in 2025: Did the Market Perform?

Windmark Beach remains one of the most sought-after master-planned communities along Florida’s Forgotten Coast. But as the real estate market shifted over the past year, many homeowners began asking the same question:

Did Windmark Beach homes for sale still perform in 2025?

To answer that, we analyzed real MLS data from the prior 12 months, including sold homes, active listings, pricing trends, and days on market. The results reveal a strong community—but one where strategy mattered more than ever.

Windmark Beach Real Estate Sales: Strong Activity, Consistent Demand

Over the last 12 months, Windmark Beach recorded approximately 90 closed home sales, averaging 7–8 sales per month. This places Windmark among the most active residential communities in Gulf County.

Key Windmark Beach sales stats:

• Total sales volume: ~$47.6 million

• Average sold price: ~$541,000

• Wide range of product types: townhomes, single-family homes, and new construction

Bottom line: Windmark Beach homes for sale continued to attract buyers throughout 2025.

Pricing Trends: What Windmark Beach Sellers Experienced

One of the most important indicators of market health is how close homes sell to their asking price.

In 2025:

• Homes sold for an average of 97.9% of list price

• Many properties sold at or near full asking price

• Correct pricing at launch played a major role in success

However, homes priced aggressively or based on outdated market expectations tended to remain on the market longer.

Days on Market: A Shift Toward a Strategy-Driven Market

The average days on market for sold Windmark Beach homes was 109 days. While that may sound high at first glance, the story becomes clearer when broken down:

• Well-priced homes often sold much faster

• Overpriced listings lingered well beyond 120–200 days

• Higher-priced homes required careful positioning and patience

This reflects a move away from the rapid seller’s market of prior years and toward a balanced market that rewards preparation and pricing accuracy.

Active Listings: What Today’s Windmark Beach Inventory Tells Us

At the beginning of 2025, Windmark Beach had 38 active homes for sale, with:

• Average list price: ~$727,000

• Average days on market: 133 days

• Many homes priced above recent sold averages

When compared to recent sales:

• Windmark Beach currently has ~5.1 months of inventory

• This indicates a balanced market, not an oversupplied one

However, the pricing gap between active listings and recent sales suggests increasing pressure on sellers who are slow to adjust.

What This Means for Windmark Beach Homeowners

Windmark Beach remains a desirable community—but selling successfully in 2025 required more than simply listing.

Successful sellers:

• Priced based on recent Windmark Beach sales data

• Used professional marketing and exposure

• Understood where their home fit within the community

Homes that struggled typically:

• Entered the market overpriced

• Sat longer and required reductions

• Lost leverage with buyers over time

Final Takeaway: Did Windmark Beach Home Sales Perform in 2025?

Yes—but not automatically.

Windmark Beach continues to be one of the strongest communities on Florida’s Forgotten Coast. Sales volume remains healthy, buyer demand is steady, and long-term value is intact. But today’s market rewards data driven pricing, strategy, and local expertise.

If you’re thinking about selling in Windmark Beach, understanding how the market actually performed—not how it used to perform—can make a significant difference in your outcome.

2026 Outlook: What’s Ahead for Windmark Beach Home Sales

Looking ahead to 2026, several key factors are aligning that could support continued sales activity in Windmark Beach, particularly for homeowners who price and position their homes correctly.

One of the biggest drivers is ongoing new construction by D.R. Horton, which continues to introduce new buyers to the community. New construction activity historically benefits resale homes by:

• Increasing overall buyer traffic into Windmark Beach

• Establishing price benchmarks for newer inventory

• Keeping Windmark top-of-mind for buyers relocating to the area

At the same time, mortgage rates are widely expected to stabilize or trend lower compared to recent highs. Even modest rate reductions can significantly improve buyer affordability and expand the buyer pool—especially in communities like Windmark Beach where homes appeal to both primary residents and second-home buyers.

What this likely means for 2026:

• Continued buyer interest across multiple price points

• Strong competition for well-priced resale homes

• Less patience from buyers toward overpriced listings as options increase

For sellers, this creates a strategic window. Homes that enter the market early and competitively priced are more likely to benefit from renewed buyer confidence and increased activity as conditions improve.

Why This Matters for Windmark Beach Homeowners

Markets don’t reward waiting as much as they reward preparation. As new homes continue to come online and buyer demand strengthens, sellers who understand where their home fits within the Windmark Beach market will be best positioned to succeed in 2026.

Thinking About Selling or Buying a Home in Windmark Beach?

We closely track Windmark Beach homes for sale, including pricing trends, inventory levels, and buyer behavior within the community. If you’d like a personalized market analysis for your home—or want to know how it compares to recent sales—we’re happy to help. The Peevy Team – proudly serving Florida's coastline since 1998!

👉 View current Windmark Beach homes for sale (click here)

or

👉 Request a custom home value report today (click here)